Talk About Network

Google





Music > Band > Re: The Band in...
Latest [ Topics | Posts ] Archive Post A New Topic Post a Reply
<< Topic < Post Post 6 of 8 Topic 483 of 562
Post > Topic >>

Re: The Band in I'm Not There

by "Peter Stone Brown" <psb51@[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Dec 5, 2007 at 01:15 AM

"KingHarvest" <a.c.joven@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote in message 
news:1888a8b0-f897-4c06-ba54-d95b00dc9a0a@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>
> PSB,
>
> That's undoubtedly what Manuel did. Maybe I saw that scene wrong or
> there was a gross oversight in the footage. Have you seen the film to
> confirm this?
>

Yes I saw I'm Not There.  The scene was wrong in that it had Dylan
standing 
at a mic and then at the piano, but the movie wasn't necessarily trying to

be accurate about anything.  You can find a review of it I wrote at 
Counterpunch.org.

http://www.counterpunch.org/brown11302007.html

But I didn't really feel they were trying to ****tray the Band as the Band
or 
the Hawks for that matter, just a band, so in that regard the accuracy of 
the scene didn't matter.  As for Manuel leaving, I saw Dylan with Levon
and 
the Hawks in '65, and that's what happened.
 




 8 Posts in Topic:
The Band in I'm Not There
maryjacksonyoung@[EMAIL P  2007-11-27 21:56:47 
Re: The Band in I'm Not There
KingHarvest <a.c.joven  2007-11-28 11:39:29 
Re: The Band in I'm Not There
"Peter Stone Brown&q  2007-11-28 20:01:36 
Re: The Band in I'm Not There
Annie Mc <anniemcneill  2007-12-01 00:24:59 
Re: The Band in I'm Not There
KingHarvest <a.c.joven  2007-12-04 16:37:01 
Re: The Band in I'm Not There
"Peter Stone Brown&q  2007-12-05 01:15:45 
Re: The Band in I'm Not There
KingHarvest <a.c.joven  2007-12-05 15:19:04 
Re: The Band in I'm Not There
Peter Huish <huish@[EM  2007-12-05 23:41:28 

Post A Reply:
  Go here to Signup

AddThis Feed Button


About - Advertising - Contact - Frequently Asked Questions - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use - Signup

Contact
localhost-V2008-12-19 Wed Jan 7 12:04:24 PST 2009.