Talk About Network



Register and Login
Nick
Password
Register create new account Sign up is FREE and you can post replies, new topics, bookmark posts and more!
Recover lost password


Music > Music Theory > Perceived limit...
Latest [ Topics | Posts ] Archive Post A New Topic Post a Reply
<< Topic < Post Post 1 of 40 Topic 2212 of 2358
Post > Topic >>

Perceived limitations of using UC RN in an harmonic analysis

by Joey Goldstein <nospam@[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Mar 2, 2008 at 12:09 PM

It has been proposed (accused?) by Lemuel J Schenck (can I call you 
"Lemmy"?) that for some reason using upper case Roman numerals in an 
harmonic analysis in and of itself somehow puts many limitations on the 
analysis than using lower case Roman numerals would.

Anybody here care to attempt to demonstrate how merely UC RNs is 
necessarily more limited in and of itself?

I'll start it off...
The only thing I can think of is that in the systems of UC oriented jazz 
analysis that I am accustomed to there is no way to indicate inversions 
within the analysis. But then again, there isn't really any need to 
indicate inversion within the analysis because any inversion would be 
made clear by the accompanying chord symbols.
Eg. C/E (in C) would just be analyzed as I.

So, while this may appear to be a liability, it's actually an advantage 
of the system, at least the way I see it.

-- 
Joey Goldstein
<http://www.joeygoldstein.com>
<http://homepage.mac.com/josephgoldstein/AudioClips/audio.htm>
joegold AT sympatico DOT ca




 40 Posts in Topic:
Perceived limitations of using UC RN in an harmonic analysis
Joey Goldstein <nospam  2008-03-02 12:09:18 
Re: Perceived limitations of using UC RN in an harmonic analysis
"Steve Latham"   2008-03-02 18:56:47 
Re: Perceived limitations of using UC RN in an harmonic analysis
Joey Goldstein <nospam  2008-03-02 14:59:48 
Re: Perceived limitations of using UC RN in an harmonic analysis
"Steve Latham"   2008-03-02 20:41:25 
Re: Perceived limitations of using UC RN in an harmonic analysis
Joey Goldstein <nospam  2008-03-02 19:55:21 
Re: Perceived limitations of using UC RN in an harmonic analysis
"Steve Latham"   2008-03-04 19:31:56 
Re: Perceived limitations of using UC RN in an harmonic analysis
ian@[EMAIL PROTECTED] (p  2008-03-03 08:44:22 
Re: Perceived limitations of using UC RN in an harmonic analysis
Joey Goldstein <nospam  2008-03-03 09:50:10 
Re: Perceived limitations of using UC RN in an harmonic analysis
ian@[EMAIL PROTECTED] (p  2008-03-04 01:28:40 
Re: Perceived limitations of using UC RN in an harmonic analysis
Joey Goldstein <nospam  2008-03-03 21:49:53 
Re: Perceived limitations of using UC RN in an harmonic analysis
ian@[EMAIL PROTECTED] (p  2008-03-04 05:37:50 
Re: Perceived limitations of using UC RN in an harmonic analysis
"Steve Latham"   2008-03-04 22:39:16 
Re: Perceived limitations of using UC RN in an harmonic analysis
"Steve Latham"   2008-03-04 22:31:15 
Re: Perceived limitations of using UC RN in an harmonic analysis
Joey Goldstein <nospam  2008-03-02 18:27:23 
Re: Perceived limitations of using UC RN in an harmonic analysis
"Steve Latham"   2008-03-04 18:35:24 
Re: Perceived limitations of using UC RN in an harmonic analysis
LJS <ljschenck@[EMAIL   2008-03-02 22:00:26 
Re: Perceived limitations of using UC RN in an harmonic analysis
LJS <ljschenck@[EMAIL   2008-03-03 11:53:31 
Re: Perceived limitations of using UC RN in an harmonic analysis
LJS <ljschenck@[EMAIL   2008-03-04 01:03:42 
Re: Perceived limitations of using UC RN in an harmonic analysis
Joey Goldstein <joegol  2008-03-04 14:21:26 
Re: Perceived limitations of using UC RN in an harmonic analysis
"Steve Latham"   2008-03-04 22:53:47 
Re: Perceived limitations of using UC RN in an harmonic analysis
Joey Goldstein <nospam  2008-03-04 20:14:37 
Re: Perceived limitations of using UC RN in an harmonic analysis
"Steve Latham"   2008-03-10 17:49:24 
Re: Perceived limitations of using UC RN in an harmonic analysis
Joey Goldstein <nospam  2008-03-10 20:33:33 
Re: Perceived limitations of using UC RN in an harmonic analysis
"Steve Latham"   2008-03-11 17:59:42 
Re: Perceived limitations of using UC RN in an harmonic analysis
Joey Goldstein <joegol  2008-03-04 14:27:16 
Re: Perceived limitations of using UC RN in an harmonic analysis
"Steve Latham"   2008-03-04 22:58:02 
Re: Perceived limitations of using UC RN in an harmonic analysis
Joey Goldstein <nospam  2008-03-04 20:05:52 
Re: Perceived limitations of using UC RN in an harmonic analysis
Joey Goldstein <nospam  2008-03-06 00:48:16 
Re: Perceived limitations of using UC RN in an harmonic analysis
"Steve Latham"   2008-03-10 17:43:39 
Re: Perceived limitations of using UC RN in an harmonic analysis
Joey Goldstein <nospam  2008-03-10 20:31:17 
Re: Perceived limitations of using UC RN in an harmonic analysis
LJS <ljschenck@[EMAIL   2008-03-08 19:56:26 
Re: Perceived limitations of using UC RN in an harmonic analysis
LJS <ljschenck@[EMAIL   2008-03-10 16:23:02 
Re: Perceived limitations of using UC RN in an harmonic analysis
LJS <ljschenck@[EMAIL   2008-03-02 20:36:12 
Re: Perceived limitations of using UC RN in an harmonic analysis
Joey Goldstein <nospam  2008-03-03 00:21:32 
Re: Perceived limitations of using UC RN in an harmonic analysis
Joey Goldstein <nospam  2008-03-03 00:39:01 
Re: Perceived limitations of using UC RN in an harmonic analysis
ian@[EMAIL PROTECTED] (p  2008-03-03 06:12:45 
Re: Perceived limitations of using UC RN in an harmonic analysis
Joey Goldstein <nospam  2008-03-03 01:16:35 
Re: Perceived limitations of using UC RN in an harmonic analysis
ian@[EMAIL PROTECTED] (p  2008-03-03 07:14:53 
Re: Perceived limitations of using UC RN in an harmonic analysis
LJS <ljschenck@[EMAIL   2008-03-04 00:46:28 
Re: Perceived limitations of using UC RN in an harmonic analysis
LJS <ljschenck@[EMAIL   2008-03-04 00:52:01 

Post A Reply:
  Go here to Signup

AddThis Feed Button


About - Advertising - Contact - Frequently Asked Questions - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use - Signup

Contact
tan12V112 Fri Jul 4 7:26:03 CDT 2008.