Talk About Network

Google


Register and Login
Nick
Password
Register create new account Sign up is FREE and you can post replies, new topics, bookmark posts and more!
Recover lost password


Music > Music Theory > Re: Quicky abou...
Latest [ Topics | Posts ] Archive Post A New Topic Post a Reply
<< Topic < Post Post 39 of 105 Topic 2223 of 2512
Post > Topic >>

Re: Quicky about naming a chord

by Hans Aberg <haberg_20080313@[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Mar 17, 2008 at 04:18 PM

David Webber wrote:

> In 
> general there are good reasons for writing one enharmonic rather than 
> another, even in 12tet.
> 
> The point I was making is that these reasons are *least* compelling for 
> diminished sevenths and augmented triads, which are rather special 
> objects. The point about diminished and augmented chords (especially in 
> 12tet) is that their identity is rather ambiguous.

If the scale is not 12-ET, so there is no enharmonic equivalence, then 
the inversions of an diminished 7th are no longer transpositions of each 
other.

   Hans Aberg
 




 105 Posts in Topic:
Quicky about naming a chord
antalabel1@[EMAIL PROTECT  2008-03-15 05:22:56 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
"Tom K." <tk  2008-03-15 11:02:54 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
"Steve Latham"   2008-03-15 17:42:02 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
"Tom K." <tk  2008-03-15 14:10:02 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
"Steve Latham"   2008-03-15 18:39:29 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
"Tom K." <tk  2008-03-15 14:50:00 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
"Steve Latham"   2008-03-15 20:08:25 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
"Tom K." <tk  2008-03-15 16:14:04 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
"David Webber"   2008-03-17 14:28:03 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
Joey Goldstein <nospam  2008-03-15 11:35:57 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
antalabel1@[EMAIL PROTECT  2008-03-15 08:45:27 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
"Jens Rodrigo"   2008-03-15 17:00:19 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
Joey Goldstein <nospam  2008-03-15 15:06:44 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
"David Webber"   2008-03-15 22:18:48 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
Joey Goldstein <joegol  2008-03-15 16:20:35 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
LJS <ljschenck@[EMAIL   2008-03-15 16:46:48 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
LJS <ljschenck@[EMAIL   2008-03-15 16:50:07 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
"David Webber"   2008-03-17 00:42:15 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
antalabel1@[EMAIL PROTECT  2008-03-16 05:23:49 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
Joey Goldstein <nospam  2008-03-16 11:23:46 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
Joey Goldstein <nospam  2008-03-16 11:46:28 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
Joey Goldstein <nospam  2008-03-16 23:11:21 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
Neil <nhmiller@[EMAIL   2008-03-16 13:38:31 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
"Tom K." <tk  2008-03-16 17:50:23 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
antalabel1@[EMAIL PROTECT  2008-03-16 13:55:17 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
Joey Goldstein <nospam  2008-03-16 17:41:34 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
Joey Goldstein <nospam  2008-03-17 10:11:40 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
antalabel1@[EMAIL PROTECT  2008-03-16 13:58:14 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
antalabel1@[EMAIL PROTECT  2008-03-16 16:51:05 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
Joey Goldstein <nospam  2008-03-16 20:21:37 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
antalabel1@[EMAIL PROTECT  2008-03-16 17:48:55 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
LJS <ljschenck@[EMAIL   2008-03-16 20:14:19 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
"David Webber"   2008-03-17 08:04:42 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
LJS <ljschenck@[EMAIL   2008-03-17 04:17:23 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
vilen@[EMAIL PROTECTED]   2008-03-17 06:20:10 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
"David Webber"   2008-03-17 14:25:57 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
"Tom K." <tk  2008-03-17 11:05:47 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
"David Webber"   2008-03-18 08:36:28 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
Hans Aberg <haberg_200  2008-03-17 16:18:50 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
"David Webber"   2008-03-18 08:30:06 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
Hans Aberg <haberg_200  2008-03-18 15:24:15 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
"David Webber"   2008-03-18 14:48:35 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
Hans Aberg <haberg_200  2008-03-18 16:03:34 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
"David Webber"   2008-03-18 16:19:22 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
Hans Aberg <haberg_200  2008-03-18 18:33:13 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
"David Webber"   2008-03-18 18:22:52 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
Hans Aberg <haberg_200  2008-03-18 19:37:55 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
"Tom K." <tk  2008-03-18 12:09:40 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
Hans Aberg <haberg_200  2008-03-18 18:10:39 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
"Tom K." <tk  2008-03-18 13:44:10 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
Hans Aberg <haberg_200  2008-03-18 18:49:29 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
"Tom K." <tk  2008-03-18 14:16:54 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
Hans Aberg <haberg_200  2008-03-18 19:34:31 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
"Tom K." <tk  2008-03-18 15:07:19 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
Hans Aberg <haberg_200  2008-03-18 20:22:37 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
"Tom K." <tk  2008-03-18 17:33:51 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
Hans Aberg <haberg_200  2008-03-18 23:16:12 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
"Tom K." <tk  2008-03-18 19:05:38 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
Hans Aberg <haberg_200  2008-03-19 00:15:25 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
"Tom K." <tk  2008-03-18 19:59:01 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
Hans Aberg <haberg_200  2008-03-19 01:47:02 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
Hans Aberg <haberg_200  2008-03-19 02:11:56 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
"Tom K." <tk  2008-03-19 11:11:32 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
Hans Aberg <haberg_200  2008-03-19 16:23:36 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
Joey Goldstein <nospam  2008-03-19 11:38:53 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
Hans Aberg <haberg_200  2008-03-19 17:57:13 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
ian@[EMAIL PROTECTED] (p  2008-03-19 04:49:44 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
"Tom K." <tk  2008-03-19 10:55:39 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
ian@[EMAIL PROTECTED] (p  2008-03-19 04:52:24 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
Hans Aberg <haberg_200  2008-03-19 00:44:25 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
"David Webber"   2008-03-19 13:06:26 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
LJS <ljschenck@[EMAIL   2008-03-17 08:37:01 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
"Tom K." <tk  2008-03-17 14:12:08 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
"David Webber"   2008-03-18 09:28:48 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
LJS <ljschenck@[EMAIL   2008-03-17 15:43:40 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
LJS <ljschenck@[EMAIL   2008-03-18 04:42:09 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
"David Webber"   2008-03-18 14:36:21 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
vilen@[EMAIL PROTECTED]   2008-03-18 05:43:12 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
LJS <ljschenck@[EMAIL   2008-03-18 10:27:04 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
"David Webber"   2008-03-18 18:20:44 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
LJS <ljschenck@[EMAIL   2008-03-18 10:32:30 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
"Tom K." <tk  2008-03-18 13:46:40 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
LJS <ljschenck@[EMAIL   2008-03-18 11:11:59 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
LJS <ljschenck@[EMAIL   2008-03-18 16:34:44 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
"David Webber"   2008-03-19 09:53:01 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
Joey Goldstein <nospam  2008-03-19 10:56:27 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
"David Webber"   2008-03-20 10:00:09 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
LJS <ljschenck@[EMAIL   2008-03-18 17:51:03 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
LJS <ljschenck@[EMAIL   2008-03-18 17:52:30 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
LJS <ljschenck@[EMAIL   2008-03-19 07:23:36 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
"David Webber"   2008-03-19 15:46:36 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
"Tom K." <tk  2008-03-19 20:22:21 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
LJS <ljschenck@[EMAIL   2008-03-19 08:54:53 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
LJS <ljschenck@[EMAIL   2008-03-19 08:57:53 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
LJS <ljschenck@[EMAIL   2008-03-19 09:05:56 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
LJS <ljschenck@[EMAIL   2008-03-19 09:20:06 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
"David Webber"   2008-03-20 09:59:25 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
LJS <ljschenck@[EMAIL   2008-03-19 12:22:09 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
LJS <ljschenck@[EMAIL   2008-03-20 05:26:20 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
"Tom K." <tk  2008-03-20 10:33:53 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
LJS <ljschenck@[EMAIL   2008-03-20 08:40:50 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
"David Webber"   2008-03-20 18:52:35 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
LJS <ljschenck@[EMAIL   2008-03-20 08:48:47 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
LJS <ljschenck@[EMAIL   2008-03-20 16:18:07 
Re: Quicky about naming a chord
LJS <ljschenck@[EMAIL   2008-03-20 18:24:10 

Post A Reply:
  Go here to Signup

AddThis Feed Button


About - Advertising - Contact - Frequently Asked Questions - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use - Signup

Contact
tan12V112 Sun Nov 23 9:10:01 CST 2008.